Home

Advertisement

Clerval and Frankenstein: Hero and Heroine?  
02:19pm 16/11/2006
 
 
annadormineyp1
I was reading yesterday in Frankenstein and thinking about all the discussions we'd had in class over the novel. We've had some wonderful talks about it and gotten some pretty good debates going, but one of the points Dr. Kimberly made about Frankenstein cracked me up. It's true: Victor Frankenstein is so much more like the Gothic heroine than the Gothic hero. I found this quote online... the Gothic heroine is "a young, attractive woman... running in terror through an old, dark, crumbling mansion in the middle of nowhere, from either a psychotic man or a supernatural demon... terminally helpless and more than a bit screechy, but is inevitably "saved" by the good guy/future husband in the nick of time." And I thought, oh my gosh. Minus the mansion, this is Victor Frankenstein all over! He begins the novel as everything beautiful, virtuous and desirable; he winds up, however, constantly panicked and feeling in danger as Steve stalks him. He is constantly fainting and suffering mental breakdowns (the novel details a few times that he suffers illness for several months following an extreme shock).
Okay, so we've identified our heroine; just one problem left. Who's our Gothic hero? As I read today and yesterday, I discovered his identity: none other than Henry Clerval, Frankenstein's best friend! To begin with, Clerval possesses all of the qualities that would have been so valued during this Romantic time period. He is ambitious and intelligent, and holds so much enthusiasm and passion for life. He wants to travel, learn languages, and serve his country and colonization. He appreciates nature, a must for any man of stature at the time. I bet he would have known the difference between sublime, beautiful, and picturesque without being laughed at by Wordsworth. In addition to his Renaissance-man personality, he always seems to be the one supporting Victor. Consider: who nursed Frankenstein for 2 months following his first illness? Clerval. He helped keep his friend emotionally balanced after he returned home to Geneva, not to mention was his psychological aid and companion on his trip to Britain.
I might be way off base here, but I don't think so.
 
    Post - Read 6 - Add to Memories - Link
 

(no subject)
 nwichnerp1
 
04:54pm 17/11/2006 (UTC)
 
 
Clerval as the hero? He certainly does fit the bill, after all, who else would fit this very virtuous role. Well I think you made it certainly clear that it is not Victor. Your description of him fits him to a T. Although I don't know if everyone can understand where you are coming from, I certainly do. I think this is a very humorous way to look at the book of Frankentein as a whole.
 
    Reply - Thread - Link
 
(no subject)
 sconklinp1
 
09:31pm 17/11/2006 (UTC)
 
 
sconklinp1
I think that it's important that Shelley portrays Vicor as, well, weaker than the average hero. His reaction to his creation-including the breakdowns-make him more human to the reader. I think it was important for Shelley to have Victor have qualites like normal humans-not necessarily a hero-in order to properly represent mankind. I think that the important part of the novel is for the reader to realize that really anyone is capable of crossing boundaries-and therefore they will have to pay the price-for Victor, that was living in fear and dealing with the consequences of his creation.
 
    Reply - Thread - Link
 
(no subject)
 jbernholtzp1
 
10:17pm 19/11/2006 (UTC)
 
 
jbernholtzp1
Ever consider the possibilty that the monster could be the gothic hero. He has many of the traits that were listed for Clerval. Though most of them took a back seat once he learned the truth behind his existence.
 
    Reply - Thread - Link
 
(no subject)
 annadormineyp1
 
10:56pm 19/11/2006 (UTC)
 
 
annadormineyp1
uhh, Jerod, STEVE has a name... j/k.
 
    Reply - Parent - Thread - Link
 
(no subject)
 joshandersonp1
 
01:34am 20/11/2006 (UTC)
 
 
It's kind of like in Lord of The Rings. I think Sam is more of a hero than Frodo. He just whinned all the time.
 
    Reply - Thread - Link
 
(no subject)
 annadormineyp1
 
03:14am 20/11/2006 (UTC)
 
 
annadormineyp1
funny you mention that example... my dad and i always come to that consensus when we watch any lotr movie together.
 
    Reply - Parent - Thread - Link
 


Advertisement

 
 
 
Navigation  
  Previous Entry
Next Entry
 
November 2006  
 
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930
 


  Powered by
LiveJournal.com